[Analysis] Ensemble Stars Fragrance Trial Event: MELLOW DEAR US and the Sweet Poison Lurking Within Their Gorgeous Scents

[Analysis] Ensemble Stars Fragrance Trial Event: MELLOW DEAR US and the Sweet Poison Lurking Within Their Gorgeous Scents

A sweet poison lurks within their gorgeous fragrances. Unraveling the dangerous allure of all four members through their ingredient lists and an on-site investigation.

Hello. The other day, I went to a fragrance trial event for Ensemble Stars…!
This time, I'll be reporting with a focus on the fragrances of the four members of the new unit "​​MELLOW DEAR US​​."
I myself own and love several of the first-wave perfumes, and every one of them was beautifully finished, with each character's concept thoroughly distilled into scent.
That's exactly why I headed to this trial event with high expectations for this second wave, too, wondering how they would express the essence of these characters.
Image
When I compared my instincts from smelling them in person against the ingredient composition charts released in advance… I found discoveries there — new kinds of allure that I never could have imagined from their visuals or public images.
​​ATTENTION​​
  • ​​About how fragrances are perceived​​: At this trial event, the perfumes were displayed pre-applied into dedicated bottles.​​
    ​Because of this, the boundaries between the top, middle, and last notes were blurred, so the impression of a scent may differ greatly depending on when you smell it.​
  • ​​About my personal analysis​​: This article contains a great deal of my own speculation and character analysis.​​
    ​The "hidden face the scent reveals" sections lean especially heavily in that direction, so if you feel an interpretation doesn't sit right with you, please feel free to skim past those parts and enjoy the rest.​

Juis Kojika: A Pure Savon Scent Where Refreshing Fruity Sweetness Melts Together

​A clean, fresh savon scent, where refreshing citrus and the sweetness of juicy fruits resonate with the aromatic nuance of calming lavender and the gentleness of musk.​​
​(From the official description)​
​**​​
Top: Lemon / Lime / Cassis / Peach / Juniper Berry
Middle: Leafy Green / Muguet / Rose / Cyclamen / Jasmin / Gardenia / Lavender / Violet
Last: Amber / Musk / Iris / Moss / Balsam
​▼ The scent predicted from its composition​
It opens with refreshing citrus, then moves into an extremely rich, classical floral heart.
This beautiful, flawless development overlaps perfectly with Juis's image as "the perfect idol" and "the all-purpose leader."
However, at the end it lands somewhere quite weighty and mysterious, with moss and balsam, so its composition is complex — it doesn't simply end on a refreshing impression.
​[My actual first impression]​​
When I actually tried it, even though the word "apple" appears nowhere in the composition chart, it was a clean scent like "refreshing green apple" with a faint sweetness drifting through it — a "classic, crowd-pleasing good scent" that just about anyone would like. Below, I'll examine it in fine detail (fair warning: this is entirely my own delusion).
Image
​[The hidden face the scent reveals]​
​1. The trick in the ingredient list: why does it smell like "green apple"?​
​(1) The "perfectly refreshing" mask created by an olfactory illusion​
The reason it smelled like green apple even though no apple is in it.
I believe this is an "olfactory illusion" created when the Top's [Lemon / Lime (tartness) + Peach (sweetness) + Cassis (astringency)] blends together with the Middle's [Leafy Green (greenness)].
This complex blend elaborately constructs a "perfectly refreshing" mask that everyone loves.
​(2) The "crushingly heavy devotion" hidden by the perfect leader​
Without using apple straightforwardly, he intricately reacts scents together to perfectly create "a face everyone loves."
At the same time as this speaks to his mass of talent as an idol, it also gives me a sense of a certain lonely distortion.
For all his overflowing talent, it was never prepared as a "pure impulse welling up from within himself."
Between his family's complicated designs, or perhaps for the sake of a certain "someone" he feels strongly about, he elaborately controls every part of himself to perform "the perfect idol"…
I can't help but feel that Juis's complex background shows through in this very trick of the scent.
​2. The "ideal idol image" that is the spitting image of Esu​
And what surprised me was that its fragrance composition is extremely similar to that of "Esu" from "Special for Princess!," who was likewise born from NiceP.
I own Esu's perfume, and in terms of first impressions, they were honestly quite alike.
For comparison, let's look at Esu's composition.
​Reference: Esu's perfume composition​
Top: Lemon / Lime
Middle: Leafy green / Aqua / Muguet
Last: Rose / Geranium / Jasmin / Muguet / Violet
You can see that the [Lemon / Lime / Leafy Green / Muguet / Rose / Jasmin / Violet] contained in Juis's Top through Middle completely covers Esu's components.
The face of "the ideal idol," which Esu — the leader of Esprit — embodies so purely, is also worn perfectly by Juis, the leader of MELLOW DEAR US.
​(1) The "earthy humanity" in the last notes that breaks the perfect idol​​
However, while Esu's perfume ends purely, with transparent flowers (Rose / Jasmin, etc.) all the way through, Juis's perfume transforms as time passes.
What appears at the end is "Moss (oakmoss)," reminiscent of dim, dark earth, and "Balsam (resin)," used since ancient times in prayers and rituals.
​(2) The conflict and heavy obsession that the scent reveals in Juis​​
At the depths of that perfect figure everyone loves (the olfactory illusion of green apple), a dim, murky conflict swirls — his powerful feelings toward NiceP, and his inability to fully accept himself as an idol…
It's a truly sinful scent: one that makes you want to confirm with your own skin the last notes I couldn't check at the trial event, and the obsession of Juis that will surely appear there — and how it all ends.
Image
​[Overall verdict]​​
​A scent that achieves both "perfect refreshment" and "heavy passion"​​
This perfume, which sinks from a juicy citrus scent like exhilarating green apple into a classical, weighty scent, gives a somewhat flawless, "proper" impression.
It gives the impression of "a clean, approachable person" in the moment you pass by, while over time a vintage-like weight is expected to emerge — I felt it was the perfect scent for those who like refreshing fragrances but also want a touch of maturity.

Mashu Kuon: A Dangerous Scent That Sinks from an Innocent Bouquet into Mysterious Sweetness

A scent of depth and mystery: the freshness of faintly fragrant citrus leads into a herbal, transparent floral bouquet of lavender and violet, until at last the rich sweetness of balsam and vanilla lingers on as a soft, spreading afterglow.
(From the official description)

​**​​
Top: Bergamot / Lemon
Middle: Lavender / Violet / Jasmin
Last: Moss / Balsam / Vanilla / Amber / Sandalwood
​▼ The scent predicted from its composition​
From a well-ordered, proper top, it moves into quiet flowers like lavender.
This calm flow matches perfectly with Mashu's role within the group as "the balancer, the sensible one."
But from there it flips completely: the provocative sweetness of vanilla intertwines with the mystique of balsam, making this a composition that hides an extreme duality at its depths.
​[My actual first impression]​
Sweet, but a little spicy. It suits Mashu's visual image very well — cute and lively, yet with a slight touch of poison.
Though the scent is soft and sweet, there's a prickling nobility to it somewhere, and I felt its skeleton closely resembled the perfume of Esprit's "Yume."
Image
​[The hidden face the scent reveals]​
​1. The dangerous true nature hidden by the "transparent floral"​
​(1) The "adorable public face" drawn by a pure bouquet​
When you think of Mashu, he's a bright, lively, cute character overflowing with a spirit of service.
The "transparent floral bouquet" in the official description expresses exactly that — the innocent, adorable public image of Mashu — very well.
​(2) A daredevil recklessness, and the "swamp of mysterious sweetness" that sinks deep​
But open the lid, and he's a daredevil who, despite having nearly died multiple times in the past, still won't quit his art.
Even offstage, he possesses a recklessness that lets him calmly walk tightropes that make you flinch, like the DM allegations.
He lulls you into letting your guard down with his cheerful floral front, catches you off guard with a slight, prickling spiciness, and at the end, the intense sweetness of "Vanilla" and the clinging mystique of "Balsam (resin)" twine around you and drag you down deep, your grip on his true nature never quite within reach…
Mashu's signature "swamp" composition was perfectly expressed in this transformation of the last notes.
​2. The skeleton of "innocent poison" shared with Yume​
At a glance, Mashu is the group's balancer and its sensible one, but comparing his composition with Yume's makes it clear that at his core, he firmly contains a "poison that can't be handled so easily."
​Reference: Yume's perfume composition​​
Top: White peach / Bergamot / Lemon
Middle: Lavender / Violet / Jasmin
Last: Amber / Musk / Iris / Oakmoss / Sandalwood
As you can see, from the opening of "Bergamot / Lemon," through the heart of the scent, "Lavender / Violet / Jasmin," and down to the foundation of "Amber / Sandalwood / Moss," the two perfumes' skeletons match to a surprising degree.
​(1) A sharp turn from the bouquet: the "sweet, dangerous true nature" in the last notes​​
However, while Yume contains straightforward emotions and an innocent rawness in notes like "Musk" and "Iris," Mashu's last notes contain no fragrance materials that indicate purity — instead, the intense spices of "Vanilla" and "Balsam" sit in their place.
This is the true identity of a "deadly poison," in a class of its own from innocent poison (the flip side of honesty).
​(2) The adult danger and sweet trap the scent reveals​
Outwardly proper and well-ordered, yet with a clinging, heavy sweetness and an adult sensuality that won't let you escape once you step in.
Even Mashu's "dangerous allegations" become deeply convincing when you look at the scents arranged in these perilous last notes.
Image
​[Overall verdict]​​
​A sensual, adult scent that creates an "elegant opening"​​
This scent, which sinks from proper lavender into clinging vanilla and balsam, is one with a gap: "looks elegant, but is actually dangerous."
I felt it was the perfect perfume for those who like sweet scents but also want maturity, and want to give off just a little mysterious sensuality.
It's a captivating scent that quietly draws out the secret danger lurking in the depths of anyone's heart.

Nozomi Madoka: A Floral Note Hiding a Lustrous Sweetness in Its Depths

From the refreshing citrus of lemon and lime, into a beautiful, luxurious floral bouquet woven by freesia, rose, ylang-ylang, jasmine, and more. At the end, a pleasant scent of the lustrous sweetness of musk and amber.
(From the official description)
​**​​
Top: Lemon / Lime / Pear
Middle: Freesia / Jasmin / Damask Rose / Muguet / Violet / Geranium / Ylang-Ylang / Leafy Green
Last: Amber / Sandalwood / Musk / Iris
​▼ The scent predicted from its composition​
It begins with the adorable sweetness of pear, the middle overflows with passionate, sensual flowers, and at the end it wraps you in a warm, skin-like musk — an overwhelmingly affectionate scent.
Despite his sharp visual image as a cold beauty with a "queen character," judging by the composition, I received a surprisingly soft impression, without any thorns.
​[My actual first impression]​
Honestly, this may have been the most surprising scent of all.
Soft, floral, and feminine — a lovely scent.
Because his character as an idol "queen" is so strong, I had initially imagined a spicier, more idiosyncratic scent.
That's exactly why I was so surprised by the gentle, softly gorgeous scent I actually smelled.
On the other hand, some people described it as "the scent of a strong woman wearing a luxury brand," so it's a very multifaceted scent that shows a completely different face depending on who smells it, and when.
Image
​[The hidden face the scent reveals]​
​1. The "adorableness" and "deadly poison" hidden behind the queen's mask​
​(1) The "cat-like adorableness" inside the armor of strong quirks​​
The Nozomi who has gradually been revealed since his implementation certainly has his selfishness and his own firm set of rules, but he opens his mind fairly quickly to those who adore him — if anything, once he grows attached, I sense in him a sweet, cat-like adorableness.
What the scent expressed was not the "strong-quirked queen figure" Nozomi wears, but this "honest, adorable true nature" inside it — or so I believe.
​(2) The "deadly poison" like a carnivorous plant, lurking in the sweet bouquet​
However, this scent also hides a "poison" particular to florals.
The jasmine and ylang-ylang blooming in the middle notes, when concentrated, emit a raw, fleshly, decadent aroma.
Furthermore, the geranium nestled against the damask rose reveals, in fleeting moments, a blade-like metallic coldness.
The many layered flowers steal away the other person's thoughts with their sensual scent, entwining prey that carelessly draws near and never letting them go. Such a sweet poison has been set within it.
​2. The "bouquet of love" in complete agreement with Hiyori Tomoe​
Moreover, thinking that the scent resembled the perfume of Hiyori, whom I own, I broke down the ingredients — and discovered that it carries almost the exact same "extremely gorgeous, deeply affectionate floral bouquet" as Hiyori's perfume.
​Reference: Hiyori Tomoe's perfume composition​
Top: Muguet / Geranium / Magnolia / ylang-ylang
Middle: Jasmin / Rose / Violet
Last: Musk / Amber
Only the arrangement of the words differs: the six flowers at the scent's center, [Muguet / Geranium / Ylang-ylang / Jasmin / Rose / Violet], and the base of [Musk / Amber] match completely.
Unlike the other MELLOW DEAR US members, Nozomi's perfume contains none of the "sharp, cold elements" like herbs or spices at all.
​(1) The intense gap between sight and smell​
Nozomi binds himself with rules, carries a danger of sometimes self-destructing, and perfectly performs the "cold queen character" his fans demand — but the perfume would not hide Nozomi's essence.
​(2) The honest, clumsy adorableness the scent reveals​
The defenseless charm indicated by the top note of pear, and the clumsy purity spoken by the musk in the last notes.
Beneath the cold armor hid a "beloved character — otherworldly, yet somehow impossible to hate" — one who holds overwhelming warmth and affection, just like Hiyori.
Image
​[Overall verdict]​​
​A defenseless, pure floral that melts the "sharp armor"​
This scent — wrapped from the refreshing, adorable pear, through a gorgeous, passionate floral bouquet, and into a warm, skin-like musk — carries the ultimate gap: "looks like a cold beauty, but is actually deeply affectionate."
I felt it was the perfect perfume for times when you're usually perceived as cool but truly want to convey approachability, or when you want to softly show your honest warmth only to someone precious.
The scent will convey your clumsy yet pure adorableness in your stead.

Chitose Tsuzura: A Refined Herbal Note and the Lustrous Sweetness of an Adult

To refreshing lemon and bergamot, a bitter lime. Over them layer the cool, herbal scents of eucalyptus and rosemary. At the end, a stylish, refined scent where the lustrous sweetness of amber and vanilla harmonizes beautifully with leather, which carries a masculine impression.
(From the official description)
​**​
Top: Bergamot / Lemon / Lime
Middle: Eucalyptus / Lavender / Rosemary / Petitgrain / Jasmin / Rose / Muguet / Violet
Last: Vanilla / Amber / Sandalwood / Cedarwood / Cardamom / Leather
​▼ The scent predicted from its composition​
It starts with clean citrus, and at a glance, has a soft sweetness true to his visual image of a "gentle, fine young man / prince."
However, from the cold, sharp herbs like eucalyptus that follow, and the stimulation of cardamom and the astringency of leather, one can read a composition that hides a complex, dangerous face beneath the prince's mask.
​[My actual first impression]​
For the other three, my impressions came together fairly quickly, but Chitose alone was hard to describe, and I found myself smelling him again and again.
In terms of strength, his scent is a little weaker than the other three.
Looking only at the composition, it holds some fairly strong-quirked elements like eucalyptus and leather, but at the point of a single sniff, I didn't feel anything particularly out of place.
A clean, harmless, well-ordered, lovely scent that anyone would like, true to his visual image.
But later, an indescribable "quirk" gradually rears its head.
This quirk was also the cause of my struggle to pin down the impression of Chitose's scent.
Image
​[The hidden face the scent reveals]​
​1. The "masculine scent" rising from beneath the sweet prince's mask​
​(1) The package of "the ideal prince," loved by everyone​​
Chitose, the group's all-rounder and its "prince," shows everyone the face of an idol loved by all.
However, just as many people who tried the scent at the event stirred, saying "it starts out soft, but later I suddenly feel its masculinity," I believe the true essence of Chitose's perfume lies in this intense gap.
​(2) A masculine, dangerous "swamp" that drags you in the moment you let your guard down​
What the perfume expressed was a swamp structure with no escape: it completely disarms the other person with its outward "harmless, gentle figure," and the moment they carelessly step in, it shows them its masculine, dangerous true nature.
The image of a dangerous-smelling man hidden behind the looks of a storybook prince, and an unfathomable quality, as if he has the other person in his grasp — that, I believe, was the true identity of this indescribable scent.
​2. A "clean" side similar to Kanna​​
Because I own Kanna's perfume and thought their scent impressions were a little similar, I compared their ingredients.
From the top into the middle, his is composed of a clean sweetness so well-ordered it's almost without individuality — something that also runs through Kanna's.
​Reference: Kanna's perfume composition​
Top: Lemon / Lime
Middle: Leafy green / Aqua / Muguet
Last: Musk / Amber
Chitose, too, has [Lemon / Lime] in the top and [Muguet] in the middle, composed as a soft, refreshing scent whose first impression puts the other person at ease.
The reason his scent felt weaker than the other three at first is likely because he intentionally shows this "face loved by everyone" in the top notes.
​(1) The indescribable "poison" that creeps in later​​
However, while Kanna ends with transparency (Aqua / Musk) all the way through, from behind Chitose's sweet mask, as time passes, the inorganic coldness of "Eucalyptus" and the astringency of "Cardamom" and "Leather" prick at you like needles. This is the true identity of the "adult poison" that takes effect slowly, later on.
​(2) The cold-heartedness and domination the scent reveals in Chitose​
The episode of how, in the past, he let Nozomi live with him and provided for him, then simply "said bye-bye" when it became too much.
His unfathomable cold-heartedness — treating the other person almost like a pet, able to cleanly cut off his own attachment — is perfectly expressed in this scent of sterile-room-like herbs, and of leather, hinting at domination (a collar).
He enters with a sweet, gentle face at first, and before you know it, he's dominating you so you can't escape…
It's a scent that embodies the unfathomable depths of the man named Chitose.
Image
​[Overall verdict]​​
​From fragrant sweetness and exhilarating citrus, into refined masculinity​
From a clean citrus scent liked by everyone, into inorganic herbs, and then dangerous leather and sweet vanilla.
At first it pretends to be "a crowd-pleasing good scent," but later reveals a complex, indescribable true nature — a very mysterious, stylish scent.
You want to keep a clean approachability, yet wear a cool, intellectual aura, as if to say "I won't let anyone step into my heart."
I felt it was the perfect perfume for those who want to project such an uncompromising strength of core.
Image

Conclusion

It was an incredibly rich experience, in which the "lie of sight" that is the visual was magnificently exposed by the "truth of smell" that is perfume.
I'm now looking forward, more than I can say, to seeing how they show us these "hidden faces" within the story in the future, and to bringing them home with me to confirm how the last notes melt together on my own skin.
In any case, MELLOW DEAR US is intense! The kinds of scents mixed into them span a wide range, and in the last notes they show off their individuality and their poison — their allure is immeasurable…!
Everyone, please do confirm their "true figures" for yourselves through scent.
And as for me, I intend to buy all of them…!